https://lit.proz.com/forum/arabic/60988-arabic_commas.html
This site uses cookies. Some of these cookies are essential to the operation of the site, while others help to improve your experience by providing insights into how the site is being used. For more information, please see the ProZ.com privacy policy.
Cookie settings

Forumai kitomis kalbomis (išskyrus anglų) » Arabic »
Arabic commas
Gijos autorius: Nesrin
Nesrin
Nesrin  Identity Verified
Jungtinė Karalystė
Local time: 02:23
iš anglų į arabų
+ ...
Dec 5, 2006

This is just a very minor issue but it's beginning to irritate me - lately I've been proofreading a lot of Arabic documents where the commas used are these
,
instead of these
،
To me this looks plain wrong, so I find and replace them, which doesn't really take long (but can be dangerous if the commas appear in numbers and shouldn't be replaced). But is this acceptable? Anyone know a reason for this increased use?
 
Stephen Franke
Stephen Franke
Jungtinės Amerikos Valstijos
Local time: 18:23
iš anglų į arabų
+ ...
Mental laziness or haste by the translator/typist AND the editor Dec 5, 2006

Dear Nesrin... ahalan wa sahalan...

Re your good question: "...anyone know a reason (for this increased use of incorrect Arabic commas in documents)?"

Comment/observation: Having encountered that feature in (way too) many Arabic products, I would ascribe that faulty practice to mental laziness or haste on the part of two main actors in that translation:

1. The translator/typist - who did not set or use the complete features of Arabic language support whil... See more
Dear Nesrin... ahalan wa sahalan...

Re your good question: "...anyone know a reason (for this increased use of incorrect Arabic commas in documents)?"

Comment/observation: Having encountered that feature in (way too) many Arabic products, I would ascribe that faulty practice to mental laziness or haste on the part of two main actors in that translation:

1. The translator/typist - who did not set or use the complete features of Arabic language support while doing the typing/word-processing

AND

2. The editor - here making a reasonable supposition that an editor was involved in the production cycle before the final Arabic product was delivered into the customer's hands or otherwise "hit the streets."

Amateurs show themselves by such sloppiness.

Khair, in shaa' Allah.

Regards,

Stephen H. Franke
San Pedro, California ▲ Collapse
 
Mumtaz
Mumtaz
Local time: 04:23
iš anglų į arabų
+ ...
Machine Translation Interface Dec 5, 2006

Nesrin wrote:

Anyone know a reason for this increased use?


Yes, I know. That's because most translators use machine translation softwares without setting the language to Arabic.
I came a cross this problem when used Golden Wafi v1.12 in 2004, I managed to solve it by changing the interface to Arabic.

Regards
 
AhmedAMS
AhmedAMS  Identity Verified
Rusijos Federacija
Local time: 05:23
iš anglų į arabų
+ ...
Non-professionalism Dec 5, 2006

Amateurs show themselves by such sloppiness.
For me, I would say that Stephen put it correctly. I bet that it is mediocre quality as well.


Nesrin wrote:

(but can be dangerous if the commas appear in numbers and shouldn't be replaced).


Would you allow me to ask about the decimal point?
Please clarify if you mean the English comma or the Arabic comma.
 
ahmadwadan.com
ahmadwadan.com  Identity Verified
Saudo Arabija
Local time: 04:23
iš anglų į arabų
+ ...
Carelessness & lack of language respect Dec 6, 2006

Nesrin wrote:

This is just a very minor issue but it's beginning to irritate me - lately I've been proofreading a lot of Arabic documents where the commas used are these
,
instead of these
،
To me this looks plain wrong, so I find and replace them, which doesn't really take long (but can be dangerous if the commas appear in numbers and shouldn't be replaced). But is this acceptable? Anyone know a reason for this increased use?


Hi Nesrin,
As for reasons: I think (Carelessness & lack of language/style/QA respect).

To overcome places where there are numbers you can apply Find & Replace to selected sections where there are no numbers or apply to all then change the places of numbers by the same way.

Kind regards
http://wadan.arablish.com

English-Arabic Financial Translator
English-Arabic IT Translator
 


To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator:

Šio forumo moderatoriai
Abdallah Ali[Call to this topic]
Murad AWAD[Call to this topic]

You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request »

Arabic commas


Forum rules
Help and orientation




Pastey
Your smart companion app

Pastey is an innovative desktop application that bridges the gap between human expertise and artificial intelligence. With intuitive keyboard shortcuts, Pastey transforms your source text into AI-powered draft translations.

Find out more »
Wordfast Pro
Translation Memory Software for Any Platform

Exclusive discount for ProZ.com users! Save over 13% when purchasing Wordfast Pro through ProZ.com. Wordfast is the world's #1 provider of platform-independent Translation Memory software. Consistently ranked the most user-friendly and highest value

Buy now! »